The first issue is understanding the life cycle of this pest.
The adult crane fly emerges from the soil from late August to
mid-September. They immediately mate and lay eggs. This is not
the time to take any action. The eggs in the soil quickly hatch
and gray-brown, worm-like larvae, with a tough skin, called
a leatherjacket starts to develop and feed on roots. The feeding
slows dramatically in the winter and recommences in early spring.
Feeding ends in mid-May. The larvae change to a quiet pupa in
July and August to appear as adults in August and September.
Enter the other European
It is important to understand that there are many natural forces
that reduce the population of crane fly larvae in the soil,
without any intervention. There can be significant death of
leatherjackets in the winter due to cold and disease. There
is also significant predation by birds feeding on the larvae.
The European Starling, that aggressive bird that drives away
native songbirds from our yards, has a redeeming value in being
a very effective leatherjacket predator. They also can serve
as an early warning sign that there is (or was) crane fly larvae
in your lawn. So, let them feed to their heart's content.